March 25, 2009
- A propos my recent trilogy on the media and politics in Turkey,
it's interesting to read the different takes on the initial reports
circulating about the apparent suicide of the head of the Turkish
Special Forces, a branch of the national police. In the version reported by Hurriyet, a newspaper that is owned by Dogan holding (whose owner, Aydin Dogan, is currently in a war of words with Turkish Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan, and whose company has recently been hit with a whopping $490 million tax bill
that threatens the existence of the company), Special Forces head
Behcet Oktay shot himself Wednesday morning after being linked to
allegations of wrongdoing in the ongoing Ergenekon investigation (the English language version also mentions the Ergenekon angle). On the other hand, Zaman newspaper, which is seen as a supporter of Erdogan's AK Party government, makes no mention of the Ergenekon investigation in its English-language reporting of the event. On its Turkish site, Zaman raises the possibility of the suicide having been related to a "forbidden love."
What's the significance of this? Opposition newspapers (among which Dogan holding's papers—such as Hurriyet, Milliyet, and Radikal—should now be included) are complaining that the Ergenekon investigation
is turning into a witch hunt against the military and the opposition.
Expect them to attempt to make some political hay out of the suicide.
Supporters of the AK Party, like Zaman (and, in the eyes of many people here, Taraf)
treat the Ergenekon investigation more at face value, and usually pay
little or no attention to accusations that the investigation is being
used, in part, as a pretext to intimidate the opposition. Expect them
to downplay this angle. As of early Thursday morning Taraf wasn't even covering the suicide on its website.
Who
knows? Maybe the suicide really was about "forbidden love." Or maybe it
was because of the Ergenekon investigation. The point is that, by
looking closely at details like this, it is possible to gain some
understanding regarding where a newspaper's sympathies lie vis-a-vis
the folks in power. And issues related to Ergenekon constitute the
biggest litmus test of all.
- The Dogan Group newspapers, meanwhile, are not even pretending
to be objective in their reporting of the massive fine the Turkish
finance ministry has levied upon the Dogan Group. On the first page of
the website of Hurriyet-English, readers are invited to read a "Special
Report on Dogan's Unfair Tax Fine." Cumhuriyet,
meanwhile (which is, however, no friend of the Dogan Group) published a
rare front-page editorial on Monday denouncing the tax levy as an
assault on Turkey's free press. Taraf and Zaman have been considerably more mealy-mouthed on the issue, sticking mainly to detail-type stories such as the huge sell-off of Dogan Holding shares on the Istanbul stock exchange this week in response to the investigation.
- Meanwhile, as of early Thursday morning, Hurriyet
was entirely ignoring a story that has made big news internationally,
Democratic Society Party (known as DTP in Turkish, and considered a
pro-Kurdish rights party) leader Ahmet Turk's addressing his parliamentary group in parliament in Kurdish.
Speaking Kurdish at all has been illegal at various times in Turkish
history, and even today it is illegal to address people at political
rallies in Kurdish or distribute campaign literature in Kurdish.
Turk
is placing Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan in a difficult position ahead
of nationwide municipal elections on March 29. Traditionally, Erdogan's
AK Party has done well in the Kurdish southeast, and this year the AK
Party is putting a lot of effort into building the party up in the
region (such as through the AK Party governor of Tunceli's
efforts—which were later disqualified by the elections board—to distribute hundreds of free appliances
to area residents last month). Indeed, while Turk's use of Kurdish
today does not appear to break the law (he was speaking to his own
parliamentary group, not at a political rally), Erdogan (who is
Turkish) actually has used Kurdish recently at a rally, saying the sentence "May TRT6 be beneficial" in Kurdish
to commemorate the opening of a new government-operated television
channel, TRT6, which broadcasts in Kurdish for several hours each day.
Erdogan is
now in the uncomfortable position of either denouncing Turk's actions
and losing votes with a constituency he has been wooing lately, or else
losing votes among Turks angered by Turk's use of Kurdish if Erdogan is
perceived as not responding aggressively enough.
- The
Ibo Show, Ibrahim Tatlises' weekly variety program, is supposedly going
off the air after eighteen years of singing, discussion, the holding of
some occasionally slimy interviews, and controversy. In an announcement
released on Wednesday, Tatlises claimed the decision to end the show
was his own, following his hurt feelings on the heels of an on-air confrontation he had last Sunday with singer Yildiz Tilbe.

End of the line? Ibo calls it quits
after on-air spat.
|
Comments